How to Make a Custom Candy Box of Sweets for Your Sweetie

Nix the nougat and deliver a Valentine’s Day gift they’ll really love.

Raise the bar this Valentine’s Day by making your loved ones their own personalized box of candy sweets instead of one of the pre-made combos you’ll find on any retailer’s shelf. By customizing the box of treats to match their personal preferences, you’re able to guarantee that the recipient will love the treats they’ll be devouring. (They’ll also feel a lot less like their playing a game of taste bud roulette – no mysterious nougats or rock hard caramels.) 

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

Custom box of chocolates for Valentine's Day

Photo by: Emily Fazio

Emily Fazio

Find a box or a tin with a lid. It doesn’t need to be a heart, mind you, but it’s certainly nice if you can find one. If you plan to reuse an old tin, keep in mind that you can also spray paint the outside of the container pink or red to suit the theme of the holiday. 

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

Custom box of chocolates for Valentine's Day

Photo by: Emily Fazio

Emily Fazio

Add a handful of colorful confetti to the bottom of the container for effect. You can use a heart-shaped hole punch like I did, or simply cut paper with scissors into teeny-tiny little pieces that flutter about and add color and whimsy to your gift. It’s a nice touch. Atop the confetti, layer miniature cupcake liners to fill the bottom of the box.

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

Custom box of chocolates for Valentine's Day

Photo by: Emily Fazio

Emily Fazio

Unwrap the special desserts you’ve selected for the recipient. The candies don’t need to be out of their wrappers, but it helps keep the element of surprise involved with the gift. You probably know what types of treats the recipient likes – mint, peanut butter, caramel, sour gummies – but if it’s a big mystery, just go for 100% truffles (the odds of losing with truffles are very low, all chocolate-loving statisticians will agree). 

Position the sweets into the individual cups. Those little pink hearts? Handmade marshmallows that are so fresh and so fluffy, no one could say no! Whoever’s getting this box is probably the luckiest person ever.

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

Custom box of chocolates for Valentine's Day

Photo by: Emily Fazio

Emily Fazio

If your box or tin is deep enough to hold two layers of goodies, add more cupcake liners and stack another round of treats. Seal it up with the lid, and be ready to make someone’s Valentine’s Day very, very special.

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

How to Make a Custom Box of Mixed Chocolates

Custom box of chocolates for Valentine's Day

Photo by: Emily Fazio

Emily Fazio

Keep Reading

Next Up

Last Minute Valentine's Day Gift Ideas

Egads, it's almost Valentine's and you're still stumped for a gift? Try one of these last-minute life savers.

10 Valentine's Flower-Buying Tips From a Bloom-Crazy Guy

Think red roses are the end-all? Want to save money on flowers this year? Get great flower tips from an expert to make your Valentine's Day one for the ages.

Ombre Candles Bring the Chic to Your Valentine's Day

Ombre is in and these pretty, easy to make candles are perfect for gifting or make a stylish addition to your holiday table.

How to Hand-Letter An Envelope

If you have a Pinterest board full of calligraphy and hand lettering inspiration, stop dreaming and start doing. It's easier than you might think to get the look of hand lettering and calligraphy.

How to Make a Puffy Paint Valentine's Day Card

Whip up a batch of DIY puffy paint with the kids.

How to Make Gift Bags Out of Duct Tape

Make customized wine caddies using cardboard and decorative duct tape. These bags are great for wine because they're waterproof, reusable and slightly thermal, so they will keep beverages cool.

How to Make a Handcrafted Holiday Tea Bag Gift

Create warm and cozy holiday memories with this thoughtful DIY gift.

12 Homemade Gift Ideas From Made + Remade

Begin checking off that holiday list with a DIY gift that shows you care.

A Creative DIY Cork Planter for Mom

Make this useful planter to decorate mom's desk for Mother’s Day.

How to Make Conversation Heart Bath Bombs for Valentine's Day

Nothing says Valentine’s Day like conversation hearts. Take that concept to the bathtub with heart-shaped bath bombs.

On TV

On TV

Get Social With Us

We love to DIY. You love to DIY. Let's get together.

Consult Our A-Z Guide

Everything You Need to Know

Browse a full list of topics found on the site, from accessories to mudrooms to wreaths.  

How-To Advice and Videos

Get video instructions about kitchens, bathrooms, remodeling, flooring, painting and more.

Watch DIY Downloads Now

Watch DIY Network LIVE

Don't miss your favorite shows in real time online.