Compost: Should You Buy or DIY?

Get valuable hints to help you decide whether to buy compost or make it yourself.
Spray Leaves for Composting

Spray Leaves for Composting

Photo by: DK - Simple Steps to Success: Lawns and Groundcover © 2012 Dorling Kindersley Limited

DK - Simple Steps to Success: Lawns and Groundcover, 2012 Dorling Kindersley Limited

When applied to a garden, compost can do fantastic things for soil and plant health. If you have space, time and interest in composting at home, it can be a fantastic way to recycle your landscape and kitchen scraps, reduce the amount of waste you send to a landfill, and create a product that you’re proud to use and share. However, even if you do compost at home, there may be times when you need to supplement by buying compost to meet the demands of your landscape. Below are some valuable hints to help you decide whether to buy compost or DIY.

Bagged Compost

Bagged compost can be picked up from most garden centers, nurseries or box stores. The cost of bagged compost may be a bit higher than from other sources, because in addition to paying for the compost, you are also paying for the packaging and associated shipping costs. However, the packaging also makes it a bit easier to load and cleaner to transport home from the store than un-bagged compost.

Municipal Compost

A growing number of towns, cities and counties are starting compost programs as a way to divert green waste from landfills. Your local government may offer curbside collection of fall leaves, branches and other yard waste during the year. This material is taken to a large facility where staff will monitor and encourage decomposition. It’s usually relatively inexpensive to buy this compost. 

However, the quality of municipal compost tends to vary between and within batches. This is understandable when you consider the fact that the ingredients came from thousands of individual landscapes across the area. Municipalities with limited means may not be able to ensure composting operations are done in a way that kills weed seeds and plant pathogens, which means that these pests could hitch a ride to your garden in the compost you buy. 

If your compost pile at home can achieve temperatures high enough to kill pests (135 degrees Fahrenheit for a few days after mixing thoroughly), consider letting municipal compost cook a little longer in your pile at home before adding to the garden.

Local, Professional Sources

An enthusiastic new breed of professional composters is popping up to fill the demand for high quality compost. They may collect materials from local farms, zoos, restaurants, landscapers and tree service companies to create their product. Before purchasing, consider doing an interview or asking for a tour of the facility. You’ll want to know what ingredients they use and whether their piles become hot enough to kill weeds and plant pathogens. If they don’t offer delivery services or only deliver by the truckload, transporting smaller amounts in your personal vehicle could get a bit messy. Professional compost will probably be a bit more expensive than municipal compost, but the finished product will usually be fairly consistent and of good quality.

Gardening Tips: Composting 03:14

Learn how to make a simple compost bin that lets nature do the work.

Next Up

Plastic Tumbler Compost Bins

Consider these important factors if you're planning on making a tumbling compost barrel.

The Different Types of Compost Bins

If you choose the right design for your experience level and budget, making a homemade compost bin will be easy.

How to Build a Wood Compost Bin

Before you build a compost bin, check out these tips and tricks for getting it set up and started.

What is Bokashi Composting?

Learn the technique of Bokashi composting and how you can try it at home.

DIY Compost Pens

Consider these important factors when planning to build your own moveable compost bin.

How to Make Compost Tea

Give your garden the benefits of compost and organic fertilizer with less work by brewing and using compost tea.

How to Make Organic Compost

Understand what it takes for compost to be considered suitable for strict organic gardening.

How to Compost and the Different Types of Compost Bins

Learn about the different types of compost bins and what household items can be composted.

The Benefits of Compost

Often called "black gold," compost is valued for giving plants a boost when added to the soil of garden beds. Learn how to give your compost pile the jumpstart it needs.

Tips for Compost Tools

To keep your composting process running smoothly, consider investing in some of these handy tools.

Get Social With Us

We love to DIY. You love to DIY. Let's get together.

Discover Made + Remade

See the latest DIY projects, catch up on trends and meet more cool people who love to create.

Make It. Fix It. Learn It. Find It.